Blue Bay Diner

Reviews

• Kevin Sanford

  star star star star star 29 September 2026

  I haven't been to the Blue Bay Diner since before my parents moved to Florida,that was like 15 years ago... That said I went there to have breakfast with a friend and had a wonderful experience.. I ordered the Greek Omelette home fries my fried ordered eggs and sausage,home fries....Bill came out for 2 people to be $42,when other places I know I've ate ate maybe $24 at best... However my dish was crowded with food and it had the most food of any place I've been to prior,so naturally I had to take most of it home.... The Omelette was perfect not too soggy or well done excellent taste,the home fries were to die for seriously I haven't had such well made home fries for years.... Well the lunch specials range in the $29+ range Other places by me $9.99-$16 for lunch....Dinners are way more expensive..... My take on the high prices are that if every meal you order you get a massive amount of food each time good for 2 meals in fact then that evens out to the other diners where the portions aren't nearly as large (in fact a diner by me for $11.99 for main choice and soup and soda the portions are small that sometimes I'm still hungry.. We had one of the nicest waitresses names Sabina,she was awesome very friendly and professional.Magnificent customer service... I even needed to tell the manager Rafael how good she was and about my nice experience there.btw,Rafael was so nice as well.... I will be making the Blue Bay Diner visits more frequent now...

• Jason Nadler

  star star star star star_border 25 September 2026

  Stopped here for breakfast. Typical NY dinner menu and pricing. Service was good, food came fast and was nicely cooked. I had French toast with eggs, scrambled eggs, as is usual, were seasoned. French Toast, I asked for double dipped and it was. I also asked for it cooked well, and it was.... Wet inside and crunchy outside, as I like it. Coffee was readily refilled. Parking was easy and access good.

• Ashkarn Singh

  star star star star star_border 21 September 2026

  The atmosphere here is okay. Menu is kind of hard to read due to the font used. Asked for fries and they said they don't have normal fries and only have home fries while we saw another table being served fries. Food took forever to come - about 45 minutes. Burger was cooked very well but wasn't anything special.

• Omar Foronda

  star star star star star 9 September 2026

  I have been to this place many times. Everything I've had here was very tasty and well presented. Staff is very, very kind, friendly and attentive. Plenty of parking and it's right off the LIE expressway. You will not be disappointed. I have not yet had the sizzling meats I've seen carried to tables, but they looked tasty and a must have.. Best diner I have ever been to..

• Hector Barrios

  star star star star star_border 9 September 2026

  This is a great diner located very convenient to where I live. Like all diners the menu is quite extensive, the service is always first rate and the food is excellent. I love the fish and chips it's always hot and tasty and they give blue cheese dressing and cocktail sauce on the side. The only reason not 5 stars is because for some reason all the diners in Flushing seem to be a bit pricier than the rest in the area, but the food consistency is 1st rate. It's always busy here and everyone is Lways all smile. Service here is excellent from the moment you enter until u leave. It won't disappoint.